Brutal reprisals, curtailed freedoms and a culture of fear: where now for the human rights crisis in Egypt?
Time and time again, Egypt proves that the situation for human rights can further deteriorate. Human rights defenders and independent civil society organisations are frequently subjected to retaliatory measures and attacks, which have increased since anti-government protests started on 20 September, catalysed by allegations of corruption. As expressed in the recent urgency resolution by the European Parliament, the deplorable situation for human rights in Egypt must no longer be tolerated. The recommendations submitted during the UN Universal Periodic Review of Egypt must be followed up on.
Prosecution grants impunity for ANHRI director’s attackers
The Arabic Network for Human Rights Information (ANHRI) reported that the investigation into the physical assault of their director, Gamal Eid, and the theft of his car had been concluded abruptly by the prosecution, without hearing his testimony or those of witnesses. Such an action by the prosecution allows the perpetrators of these appalling crimes to escape punishment and further undermines the rule of law in Egypt. For full details, see here.
Following a release order, human rights lawyer Ibrahim Metwally accused in a new case
The supreme state security prosecution interrogated human rights lawyer Ibrahim Metwally in state security case 1470/2019 and decided to detain him for 15 days, on charges of joining a terrorist group and funding terrorism. He has already spent over two years in pre-trial detention in state security case 900/2017, on the same charges. He received a release order in case 900/2017 on 14 October and was held illegally in detention for two weeks before being accused in the new case, which is a way to circumvent the two-year maximum on pre-trial detention prescribed by Egyptian law.
ANHRI human rights lawyer Rawda Ahmed’s car vandalised
Rawda Ahmed, a lawyer from the Arabic Network for Human Rights Information (ANHRI), filed report no. 23918/2019 at Basateen Police Station, after security personnel smashed her car, which was with ANHRI director Gamal Eid at the time. Gamal Eid’s own car was stolen on 30 September, yet police have refused to investigate the theft, and he was physically assaulted in the street on 10 October.
Check out our 5 last newsletters
in prison for 37 daysmore info
in prison for 57 daysmore info
in prison for 54 daysmore info
in prison for 150 daysmore info
Ibrahim Ezz El-Din
in prison for 164 daysmore info
in prison for 193 daysmore info
in prison for 347 daysmore info
Shady Al-Ghazaly Harb
in prison for 557 daysmore info
Shady Abu Zeid
in prison for 565 daysmore info
Mohamed Ibrahim (Oxygen)
in prison for 62 daysmore info
in prison for 631 daysmore info
Ibrahim Metwally Hegazy
in prison for 803 daysmore info
in prison for 1454 daysmore info
in prison for 2180 daysmore info
Alaa Abdel Fattah
in prison for 54 daysmore info
Mahmoud Abu Zeid (Shawkan)more info
Amal Fathymore info
Mostafa el Hassanmore info
Hisham Gaafarmore info
Khaled Alimore info
Magdy Abdel Hamidmore info
Suzanne Fayyadmore info
Azza Solimanmore info
Malek Adlymore info
Esraa Abdel Fattah
in prison for 41 daysmore info
Mozn Hassanmore info
Gamal Eidmore info
Mohamed Zareemore info
Negad El Boraimore info
Ahmed Raghebmore info
Abdel Hafez Tayelmore info
Aida Seif Al-Dawlamore info
Nasser Aminmore info
Hoda Abd El-Wahabmore info
Hossam Al-Din Alimore info
Hossam Bahgatmore info
Omar Hazekmore info
in prison for 37 days
Amr Imam is a human rights lawyer with the Arabic Network for Human Rights Information.
On 16 October 2019, he was kidnapped at dawn by police officers. He managed to publish a brief post on Facebook about his arrest before being taken to an unknown location, however he was refused the right to call his lawyer or family members. The following day, he appeared before the state security prosecution who decided to detain him pending investigation into case 488/2019, on charges of collaborating with a terrorist organisation, misusing social media and spreading false news and statements. He is reportedly being held in solitary confinement.
Before his arrest, he had publicly declared his intention to begin a hunger strike to protest cases of torture, ill-treatment, kidnapping and lack of accountability for crimes committed by police officers.
in prison for 57 days
Asmaa Dabees is a woman human rights defender and founder and coordinator of “Daughter of the Nile” – a feminist initiative working on issues such as violence against women, child marriage and female genital mutilation, mainly in the Beheira governorate. She is a member of the Regional Coalition for Women Human Rights Defenders in the Middle East and North Africa (WHRD-MENA Coalition).
On 26 September 2019, she was arrested from a local café in Damanhour governorate by plainclothes police officers, along with her husband and her brother-in-law, and taken to an unknown location. Her husband is a lawyer who has represented activists and political detainees. After several days of enforced disappearance, on 1 October, Asmaa and her family members appeared in Zeinhom Court to begin investigations, at the end of which the state security prosecution issued them all with a pre-trial detention order in case 1338/2019. Asmaa's detention is now regularly renewed.
Her arrest is part of a wider campaign in which over 4,400 people have been detained or disappeared since 20 September following demonstrations calling for President al-Sisi to step down.
For regular updates on Asmaa Dabees' case, follow the informal Facebook page Free Asmaa Dabees.
in prison for 54 days
Mohamed el-Baqer is a human rights lawyer and director of Adalah Center for Rights and Freedoms.
On 29 September 2019, Mohamed el-Baqer was arrested at the premises of the state security prosecution where he was attending an investigation session of the blogger and activist Alaa Abdel Fattah, who had been arrested earlier that morning. The supreme state security prosecution decided to detain Mr el-Baqer pending investigation on charges of joining an illegal group and spreading false news in supreme state security case 1356/2019. His pre-trial detention is now renewed every 15 days.
Mr el-Baqer has reportedly suffered ill-treatment during detention, such as being denied access to drinking water, sanitation and medical assistance.
His arrest is part of a wider campaign in which over 4,400 people have been detained or disappeared since 20 September following demonstrations calling for President al-Sisi to step down, and comes in the context of shrinking space for human rights organisations and human rights defenders. The UN human rights office has expressed its concerns over his arrest.
For regular updates, follow the Free Baker Facebook page.
in prison for 150 days
Zyad el-Elaimy is a human rights lawyer, former parliamentarian and a leader of the Egyptian Social Democratic Party. He was a renowned figure of the 2011 uprising, initiating the 25 January Revolution Youth Coalition and delivering speeches in Tahrir square to mobilise Egyptian citizens to stand up for democracy and against injustice. Through his work as a lawyer, he has represented activists, politicians and trade unionists.
On 25 June 2019, Zyad was arrested at dawn by plainclothes security agents and held incommunicado for 14 days. He is currently being detained in a 4.8m2 cell with two others in Tora prison where he is denied recreation rights. Zyad is in poor health, whereby he suffers from asthma, diabetes, high blood pressure and a rare immunity disease, however he has been denied appropriate medical care. Moreover, his abysmal detention conditions – including lack of proper ventilation and access to sunlight – have led to a deterioration in his health.
Zyad’s arrest was part of a widespread arbitrary arrest campaign launched at the end of June 2019 that targeted those coordinating to participate in the parliamentary elections next year through an opposition alliance called “Hope.” The Ministry of Interior issued a statement accusing Zyad and others of a plan “to carry out violent and disorderly acts against State institutions simultaneously with creating a state of revolutionary momentum,” financed by the Muslim Brotherhood. He was added to state security case 930/2019, known publicly as the “Hope” case, on charges of engaging with a terrorist group to help achieve its goals and spreading false news and statements. On 4 August, Cairo criminal court accepted a request submitted by the public prosecutor to seize the funds of the defendants in this case. Zyad’s detention is renewed by the state security prosecution every 15 days.
For regular updates on Zyad el-Elaimy’s case, follow the Facebook page @Freeelelaimy.
Ibrahim Ezz El-Din
in prison for 164 days
Ibrahim Ezz El-Din is a researcher at the Egyptian Commission for Rights and Freedoms (ECRF) specialised in housing rights.
He was arrested in the evening of 11 June 2019 near his home in the Mokattam area of Cairo and taken to an unknown location. Since then, his family have not had any contact with him. Mokattam police station denies his presence within their premises. Both ECRF lawyers and his mother have submitted communications to the Attorney General regarding his arrest and disappearance.
It is believed that his arrest is linked to his criticism of government housing and urban planning policies, including towards shanty towns, evictions and the new Egyptian administrative capital.
in prison for 193 days
Haitham Mohamedeen is a labour rights lawyer and left-wing activist.
He was in pre-trial detention from 18 May until 10 October 2018 pending investigation into state security case 718/2018, on charges of protesting the increase in the price of metro tickets, inciting others to protest, and involvement in a banned group. He was released with precautionary measures stipulating that he had to undergo police monitoring twice a week. On 5 January 2019, the court decided to reduce his precautionary measures to one two-hour visit to the police station each week.
On 13 May 2019, Mr Mohamedeen was arrested again, after he went to the police station having been told that they had not received the decision to revise his precautionary measures and that a report had been filed accusing him of not carrying out the measures. He appeared before the state security prosecution on 16 May and was detained for 15 days in a new case (741/2019), in which he faces charges of engaging with a terrorist group to help achieve its aims. His detention is regularly renewed.
He was previously arrested in 2013, accused of belonging to a secret organisation and spreading lies regarding the military, and then detained in 2016 after calling for protests following the transfer of the Red Sea islands of Tiran and Sanafir to Saudi Arabia.
in prison for 347 days
Mohamed Ramadan is a human rights lawyer based in Alexandria. He has used his legal expertise to defend human rights activists and political prisoners in Egypt. He has also worked on cases of torture in police stations. Mr Ramadan worked at the Arabic Network for Human Rights Information (ANHRI). Since 2014, he was a member of its Lawyers for Democracy Initiative, monitoring and documenting democracy in the country. He was also part of the legal team that represented woman human rights defender Mahienour El-Masry, who was sentenced to prison for violating the Protest Law.
In 2014, Mr Ramadan was detained and mistreated in a police station in Alexandria after he attempted to file a complaint against the detention of Syrian refugees at the same station. In November 2016, security forces raided his house and arrested his mother and his sister. He was detained again, interrogated in December 2016 and charged with insulting National Security on social media.
In April 2017, Ramadan was sentenced in absentia to 10 years in prison, followed by five years of house arrest and a ban on using the internet for the same period. The decision was based on violations of the counter-terrorism Law 94/2015, known for its wide definition of “terrorist act”, after he allegedly created a Facebook account expressing opinions that could potentially "disrupt public order" and "harm national unity". In 2018, Alexandria Criminal Court suspended the case until the Supreme Constitutional Court clarifies the constitutionality of some articles of the counter-terrorism Law under which he was convicted.
He was briefly arrested in June 2017 from a cafe in Alexandria, in the context of the protests against the transfer of two Red Sea islands to Saudi Arabia.
He was arrested once again in December 2018 and is being held in pre-trial detention pending further investigation. He is accused of joining a terrorist group and promoting its ideas, spreading false news, possessing pamphlets and yellow vests to call for protests against the government (similar to the ‘Yellow Vest’ protests in France) and using social media to promote a terrorist group. This was after posting a photo on Facebook of him wearing a yellow vest.
Shady Al-Ghazaly Harb
in prison for 557 days
Shady Al-Ghazaly Harb is a liberal political activist, an assistant professor of general surgery at Cairo University and a former politician in the Dustour party, as well as a well-known figure from the 2011 uprisings. His initial support for the 2013 ouster of Mohamed Morsi later turned into harsh criticism towards the current military government.
He has been in detention since 14 May 2018, following a summoning from the Giza prosecution, according to his lawyer, and is reportedly in solitary confinement. His wife, Fatima Harb, reported that despite the prompt payment of the EGP 50,000 bail, authorities refused to release him. His detention was initially renewed every 15 days by Cairo’s State Security Prosecution and then every 45 days following orders from Giza Criminal Court as of 9 October 2018. He stands accused of joining an illegal organisation, insulting president Al-Sisi and spreading false news within case 621/2018.
The case also included other activists and bloggers such as Amal Fathy, Shady Abu Zeid, Sherif el-Roubi, and Mohamed Ibrahim Radwan (Oxygen). He was among the signatories of a petition calling for a boycott of the March presidential elections in January 2018. The Egyptian Centre for Economic and Social Rights has undertaken legal action demanding the end of his solitary confinement and asking to allow him to exchange correspondence with his family.
For the latest updates on his case, follow the @FreeShadyElGhazalyHarb Facebook page.
Shady Abu Zeid
in prison for 565 days
Shady Abu Zeid is a satirist, comedian and blogger currently in pre-trial detention. He has been detained since 6 May 2018 on accusations of joining a banned group and spreading false news through Muslim Brotherhood-affiliated broadcast organisations within case 621/2018. After his arrest he disappeared for a day and a half, until his hearing before the Cairo State Security Prosecution. On 9 February 2019, Cairo criminal court ordered his release with precautionary measures, but this decision was overturned two days later. His detention has been extended by Cairo Criminal Court multiple times.
On 4 February 2017, Abu Zeid was sentenced to six months in prison in another case (1088/2018) in absentia for offending judicial officers. His lawyers appealed the sentence on 15 December 2018, but the appeal was rejected because he did not attend in person, as the prison authorities did not transfer him to court. He will be able to re-appeal once he is released in case 621/2018.
After recording a 2016 satirical video regarding national police forces on the anniversary of the 25 January Revolution for the satirical news show "Abla Fahita", he reportedly received threats from members of the police forces. This led to his family, supported by the Association for the Freedom of Thought and Expression, filing a legal complaint addressing the Interior Ministry. He has produced satirical content for social media channels like the Rich Content Facebook page and YouTube Channel since 2015, including on-street interviews with ordinary Egyptians .
For the latest news on Abu Zaid’s case search for the hashtag #الحرية_لشادي_أبوزيد on Twitter.
Mohamed Ibrahim (Oxygen)
in prison for 62 days
Mohamed Ibrahim Radwan (known as Mohamed Oxygen) is an Egyptian blogger and employee in a publishing house who, in addition to his blog, runs a Facebook page and a Youtube channel called Oxygen Egypt where he publishes reports on human rights issues and interviews with human rights activists such as Gamal Eid, opposition figures and public personalities.
He was arrested on 6 April 2018 and subjected to enforced disappearance for about a week, before being detained in pre-trial detention for over a year, on charges of publishing false news and joining an outlawed group in case 621/2018. Cairo criminal court accepted a release order with precautionary measures for him on 22 July 2019, and he was finally released on 31 July. He was allegedly held in solitary confinement and beaten in Tora prison, as well as prevented from receiving family visits.
On 21 September 2019, Mohamed Oxygen was transferred from the police station to the National Security Headquarters while carrying out the probation measures issued against him in state security case 621/2018. He was forcibly disappeared for 18 days before appearing before the prosecution where he was handed a 15-day detention order in case 1356/2019, on charges of engaging with a terrorist group to help achieve its aims, spreading false news and statements and misusing social media. His pre-trial detention is now regularly renewed. His arrest comes in the context of a widespread arrest campaign following the anti-government protests which began on 20 September.
For the latest updates on his case, follow the hashtags #أكسجين_مصر or الحرية_لمحمد_أكسجين on Twitter.
in prison for 631 days
Ezzat Ghoneim is a human rights lawyer and director of the Egyptian Coordination for Rights and Freedoms, a human rights organisation based in Cairo. He has defended political prisoners in both military and state security courts.
He was arrested in March 2018 following a BBC report on torture and accused of spreading false news and joining a banned group. Initially interrogated without a lawyer, he was then kept in Tora prison for six months. Expected to be released following a decision of the Giza criminal court in supreme state security case 441/2018, he went missing on 14 September 2018. Egyptian authorities did not provide any indication regarding his whereabouts. On 3 February 2019, he appeared before Cairo criminal court which sentenced him to 45 days in detention. His pre-trial detention is regularly renewed.
In April 2019, the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention (WGAD) issued a legal opinion on his situation, concluding that his detention contravened several articles in the Universal Declaration of Human rights and that the “appropriate remedy would be to release Mr. Ezzat immediately and accord him an enforceable right to compensation and other reparations, in accordance with international law.”
On 28 July 2019, the Egyptian authorities summoned Ezzat Ghoneim and questioned him in another case over “membership in a banned group”.
For the latest developments in Ghoneim’s case check the Twitter hashtag #عزت_غنيم_فين and the informal Facebook campaign @freeghoneim.
Ibrahim Metwally Hegazy
in prison for 803 days
Ibrahim Metwally Hegazy is a human rights lawyer and the co-founder and coordinator of the Association of the Families of the Disappeared. Metwally represents families of people forcibly disappeared by the Egyptian state and was reported for providing legal advice to the family of Giulio Regeni, the Italian Cambridge university student who disappeared on 25 January 2016 and whose body was found bearing signs of extreme torture.
Metwally was arrested on 10 September 2017 at Cairo International airport while travelling to Geneva to attend a session of the UN Working Group on Enforced or Involuntary Disappearance (WGEID). He was held in pre-trial detention for over two years in state security case 900/2017, on charges of establishing and leading an illegal group, spreading false news and communicating with foreign entities to support him in spreading his group’s ideas. During this time his health severely deteriorated due to medical neglect and he was denied visitation rights.
On 14 October 2019, the supreme state security prosecution decided to release Ibrahim Metwally Hegazy, however his release order was not implemented and on 5 November 2019 he was accused in a new case (740/2019) on charges of joining a terrorist group and funding terrorism. This is a way to circumvent the two-year maximum on pre-trial detention prescribed by Egyptian law.
in prison for 1454 days
Ismail Al-Iskandarani is one of very few well-informed journalists and researchers to have published extensively on the political, security and human rights situation in the Sinai Peninsula. He has provided rare and credible analysis of the conditions endured by the civilian population of North Sinai, an area where a sweeping counter-insurgency operation is being implemented by the military. He is an associate researcher with the Arab Reform Initiative, and was a guest researcher at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars in Washington, DC.
On 29 November 2015, Mr al-Iskandarani was detained when returning to Egypt from Germany and was held for more than ten hours at the airport of Hurghada. He was later moved to the State Security Prosecution, after the authorities searched his laptop and found articles he had written on Sinai and other political issues. He was interrogated on charges of belonging to an illegal group, the Muslim Brotherhood, and spreading its ideas, in addition to intentionally disseminating false information.
After spending more than two years in pre-trial detention, Mr Iskandarani was sentenced on 23 May 2018 to 10 years in prison by a military court. The ruling was upheld on 24 December 2018.
For updates on his situation, follow the hashtag #الحرية_لاسماعيل_الاسكندراني on Facebook.
in prison for 2180 days
Ahmed Douma is a prominent political activist in Egypt and was one of the founders of both the Kefaya and April 6 Youth Movements. He was imprisoned 18 times under the regimes of Mubarak and the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces and twice under Morsi’s presidency.
On 9 January 2019, Ahmed was sentenced to 15 years in prison and given a 6 million EGP fine by a Cairo criminal court as part of a case known as the Cabinet clashes, dating back to 2011, when military forces violently dispersed a demonstration in front of the Cabinet building and clashed with protesters. Ahmed was initially brought to court in May 2012, along with other defendants on charges of assaulting police, unlawful assembly and vandalising property. He was given a life sentence in February 2015. However, this sentence was overturned in October 2017 and his retrial began several months later, ending in January 2019. His health has deteriorated during detention.
Ahmed has also been given sentences in three other cases. In December 2013, he was sentenced to three years in prison and a fine on protest-related charges. This decision was upheld by the Court of Cassation in January 2015. He was given another three years in prison and a fine in December 2014 for insulting the judiciary. However, this sentence was overturned in May 2017 and only the fine was upheld. Finally, in January 2016, he was charged with assaulting a police office on the way to court and given 6 months in prison, subsequently reduced to one month.
Follow this Facebook page for regular updates on Ahmed Douma.
Alaa Abdel Fattah
in prison for 54 days
Alaa Abdel Fattah is an Egyptian activist, blogger and software engineer who has been at the forefront of the struggle for change in Egypt for many years. He has the distinction of having been arrested not only during Mubarak's rule but also by the different regimes that have ruled Egypt since the 2011 revolution.
Alaa previously served a five-year sentence for “organising a protest” against military trials for civilians in front of the Shura Council. This case, monitored and considered an unfair trial by EuroMed Rights, was challenged with an appeal in front of the Court of Cassation. The court delivered a final ruling in November 2017 upholding the five-year sentence. During Alaa's time in detention, his father, renowned human rights and constitutional lawyer, Ahmad Seif, died at 60 and his younger sister, Sanaa, was tried – also for protesting – and served 14 months of a two-year jail sentence.
On 29 March 2019, he was finally released and returned home. However, he was given probation measures which entailed spending 12 hours every night for the next five years locked inside a police station from 6pm to 6am.
Six months later, on 29 September, Alaa was arrested from Dokki police station where he was carrying out his 12-hour police monitoring. His family were informed that he had been taken to the state security prosecution where he was interrogated in the presence of his lawyers. One of his lawyers, Mohamed el-Baqer, was subsequently arrested. Alaa Abdel Fattah is currently being held in case 1356/2019, in which he faces charges of spreading false news and joining an illegal organisation. His arrest is part of a wider arrest campaign which has seen over 4,400 people detained or disappeared since 20 September following demonstrations calling for President al-Sisi to step down. He has reportedly been subjected to torture in custody since his arrest at the end of September, including repeated beating and being forced to remove his clothing. The UN human rights office has expressed its concerns over his arrest.
Following a ruling of the Court of Cassation on 15 October 2018, Alaa was fined with LE 30,000 in a second case for tweets allegedly questioning Egypt’s judiciary independence. The case included other 24 prominent human rights defenders - including Amr Hamzawy, as well as opposition figures.
For updates on his situation, follow the Facebook page Free Alaa.
Mahmoud Abu Zeid (Shawkan)
Mahmoud Abu Zeid, mostly known as Shawkan, is an Egyptian photojournalist who was arrested on 14 August 2013 while covering the Rabaa al-Adawiya Square protests. His case was part of the mass trial against 700 defendants who were arrested in connection with the August 2013 protests against the Egyptian military’s coup. The case is known as the “Rabaa dispersal” case.
When Shawkan was arrested, police officers did not explain the reason of his arrest nor did they present him with a warrant. He was taken to Cairo Police Station where he was detained and questioned by a prosecutor without the presence of his lawyer. He was thereafter taken to the Abu Zaabal Prison along with other detainees who were arrested in relation to the protest at Rabaa Square. Shawkan remained in detention and was transferred to the notorious Tora prison (also known as "the Scorpion") in December 2013, where he was detained in a 3 by 4 meter prison cell with 12 other individuals. He narrated the hardships of his conditions in the Tora prison in a letter to mark his 600 days in pre-trial detention, saying
"Tora prison is like a cemetery. It is a place where dreams come to die"
After spending a period of three years in extended pre-trial detention, Shawkan was eventually charged with nine offenses on 26 March 2016, including murder, putting him at risk of being sentenced to death. Other charges include joining a criminal gang, attempted murder, participating in a gathering with the purpose of intimidation and creating terror and exposing people’s life to danger, obstructing public utilities, overthrowing the regime through the use of force and violence, a show of strength and the threat of violence, resisting the authorities, obstructing the implementation of laws, surveillance, and disturbing public space.
Shawkan was only allowed to meet with his lawyers on an arbitrary basis and was not allowed to meet with his lawyers privately. On several occasions, he was denied access to his legal counsel and was not notified of several meetings and hearings that took place.
A major concern was Shawkan’s health as he was diagnosed with Hepatitis C shortly before his arrest. His family and lawyers filed several appeals to request his release on medical grounds. In the meantime, Shawkan was systematically denied any medical care. In a court session that took place on 27 December however, the judge presented a report by the Tora prison doctor stating that Shawkan was in perfect health.
On 3 March 2018, the prosecutor in the “Rabaa dispersal” case requested the death penalty (“death by hanging”) for him. No evidence was presented that could prove Shawkan’s responsibility for any of the offenses he has been charged with.
On 8 September 2018, a court sentenced him to five years in prison, which he had already served in pre-trial detention. The hearing was part of a mass trial against alleged protesters at the Rabaa sit-in of August 2013. As part of this case, 75 defendants have been sentenced to death. The UN High Commissioner for Human Rights said that the decision resulted from an unfair trial and that, if carried out, it would amount to “a gross and irreversible miscarriage of justice”.
On 4 March 2019, Shawkan was released and returned home after more than 5 years in detention. However, he is only partially free as he has to spend 12 hours every night for next five years in the police station.
For the latest updates, check out the Freedom For Shawkan Facebook Page here.
Amal Fathy is a woman human rights defender who won the Bruno Kreisky prize for human rights in May 2019, highlighting her courageous work defending human rights in Egypt. She is married to Mohamed Lotfy, who is the executive director of the Egyptian Commission for Rights and Freedoms.
Ms Fathy was arrested on 11 May 2018 after security forces raided her house, where she was present with her husband and their three-year-old child. Their phones were seized and their house searched, and then they were both taken to Maadi police station. While Mr Lotfy was released shortly after, Ms Fathy was referred to the prosecutor, who decided to hold her in pre-trial detention on the basis of alleged incitement to overthrow the ruling system, publishing lies and misusing social media, in relation to a Facebook video posted on 9 May 2018 on her Facebook account criticising the failure of the Egyptian government at protecting women against sexual harassment. This is how a first case (1997/2018) was brought against her.
Additionally, on 13 May 2018, she was charged with deliberately thwarting the presidential elections, disturbing public opinion, joining a banned group, using the internet to spread ideas calling for terrorist acts, and deliberately spreading false news that harmed public interest. These accusations are part of a second case (621/2018) that also includes online activist Mohamed Oxygen, among others.
On 19 June 2018, a judge ordered her release on bail of 10,000 Egyptian pounds, pending investigation in the first case (1997/2018). As the prosecution in the case appealed the decision, Ms Fathy had to appear before a criminal court on 21 June, which upheld the judge's decision. However she remained in detention in relation to the second case (621/2018).
On 29 September, the Maadi misdemeanour court handed her a two-year prison sentence for spreading false news with intent to harm the Egyptian state and public indecency in case 1997/2018. The appeal session on 30 December upheld this decision. She will appeal before the Cassation Court. EuroMed Rights commissioned experts from Solicitors’ International Human Rights Group (SIHRG) to observe her trial and found many breaches of Ms Fathy’s fair trial rights, namely: her right to know the details of the charges against her, to prepare a defence, and to be presumed innocent, as well as her right to legal assistance and her right to call and examine witnesses.
Conditionally released following a court order of 18 December 2018 pending investigation in case 621/2018, she returned home on 27 December. She spent over a month not able to leave her home except for medical treatment, until her probation was modified on 9 February. She is now allowed to leave home freely but is required to undergo police monitoring twice a week for four hours.
Ms Fathy risks being re-arrested at any time to serve the sentence issued in case 1997/2018.
Mostafa el Hassan
Mostafa el Hassan is a lawyer and head of the Hisham Mubarak Law Center, a Cairo-based legal organisation promoting human rights and legally supporting victims of human rights violations in Egypt.
His assets and those of the organisation were frozen in September 2016 as he was accused of establishing an organisation in violation of the NGO law and illegally receiving foreign funding in case 173/2011, known as the foreign funding case. He was added to the list of defendants, together with other human rights activists, in April 2016, then he was summoned and questioned again in case 173/2011 in April 2017, and subsequently released on bail on the same day.
For more information on the Hisham Mubarak Law Centre, visit the Centre’s Facebook page.
Hisham Gaafar is the director of the Mada Foundation for Media Development and a member of the Journalists’ Syndicate.
He was arrested when security forces stormed the headquarters of Mada on 21 October 2015. He was interrogated by the state security prosecution and his lawyers were barred from attending the interrogation. He was held in pre-trial detention on charges of receiving illegal foreign funding and belonging to the Muslim Brotherhood.
He spent most of his time in al-Aqrab/Scorpion section, the maximum-security wing of the Tora prison compound. In May 2017, a court listed Gaafar on a terrorism list. In December 2018, the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention concluded that his deprivation of liberty was arbitrary and requested his immediate release. He suffers many health problems which severely deteriorated during detention due to medical neglect and being kept in solitary confinement.
On 26 March 2019, Cairo Criminal Court ordered his release with precautionary measures, after more than three years in pre-trial detention (which greatly exceeds the maximum period of two years allowed by the law). He finally returned home late at night on 6 April 2019.
On 13 February 2019, his family submitted his application to run for the Journalists’ Syndicate's mid-term elections. However, the electoral commission of the syndicate subsequently announced that it had excluded him from the final applications after receiving an appeal from a candidate challenging his candidacy for not signing the application in person. Lawyers at the Arabic Network for Human Rights Information appealed this decision on 21 February.
For updates, follow the Facebook page Hesham Gaafar.
Khaled Ali is a human rights lawyer. He was head of the Egyptian Centre for Economic and Social Rights (ECESR), co-founded both the Front for Defending Egypt's Protesters and the Hisham Mubarak Law Centre (HMLC) and founded the Aish we Horreiya (Bread and Freedom) party. He has worked on anti-corruption issues, workers’ rights and freedom of expression, association and assembly.
He declared his intention to run for the 2018 presidency in February 2017 and withdrew his candidacy in January 2018, mentioning external pressure as a primary reason for his decision. In May 2017, charges were brought against him for allegedly making an obscene gesture in public while celebrating the Supreme Administrative Court’s decision of January 2016 rejecting an agreement to transfer two Red Sea islands to Saudi Arabia. He was subsequently sentenced to three months in prison.
Mr Ali’s appeal was dismissed and a three-month jail sentence was upheld on 19 September 2018, suspended for three years. EuroMed Rights and the Bar Human Rights Committee of England and Wales monitored the trial and published a trial observation report highlighting an inappropriate proximity between the judges and the prosecution.
On 6 October 2018 a travel ban was issued against him without any formal notification and he was added to a watch list reportedly due to his suspected involvement in case 173/2011, known as the foreign funding case. Mr Ali gave legal assistance to several defendants within the same case.
To know more about Khaled Ali and his work, follow his Twitter account here.
Magdy Abdel Hamid
Dr. Magdy Abdel Hamid has worked as a consultant on political development policies, civil society and human rights policies and training programs. He is a consultant to UN agencies, IDEA, DRI, EPD and EU. He is also the chairman of the Egyptian Association for Community Participation Enhancement (EACPE).
On 2 October 2017, while going to Amman to attend the Policy Forum on Development, organised under the EU Euro-Mediterranean Partnership, he was prevented from travelling outside Egypt.
Dr Suzanne Fayyad, co-founder of Al Nadeem Center for the Rehabilitation of Victims of Violence and Torture, was banned from travel in the morning of 18 October 2017 by Cairo airport authorities. She was informed the ban was ordered by the investigative magistrate as she was boarding a flight to Tunisia to attend a conference on the rehabilitation of child torture victims. However, she was not informed about the reasons for the order.
On 24 May 2018, Suzanne Fayyad, together with her colleague Dr Magda Adly, was summoned to appear in front of the investigating judge as part of the case 173/2011, known as the foreign funding case against NGOs.
As Al Nadeem highlighted in a statement, this decision came only a few weeks after the centre received the Amnesty International Germany’s Human Rights Award.
In February 2017, El Nadeem, the most prominent organisation providing support to victims of torture and violence in Cairo, had been shut down following an administrative order decreed one year before, upon instruction of the Health Ministry.
Azza Soliman is a prominent lawyer and the founder of the Center for Women's Legal Assistance (CEWLA). She is currently serving on its board of trustees. CEWLA is a feminist organisation that campaigns to promote gender equality, focusing in particular on legislative reform and awareness-raising.
In November 2016, Azza Soliman’s personal bank account and that of her law firm, Lawyers for Justice and Peace, were frozen by instruction of the Central Bank. Shortly after that, when trying to flight to Jordan to participate in a training on human rights, she was notified that she was banned from travelling.
In December 2016, she was arrested from her home and escorted to the police station by security forces. She was later transferred to the New Cairo court where she was interrogated by the investigative judge of case no 173, known as the foreign funding case. Released on bail in the evening, she is nevertheless currently under investigation, charged with tax evasion, receiving illegal foreign funding "with the aim of harming national security”, and founding an illegal entity.
In July 2017, two of her colleagues at the LJP, Seham Ali and Abeer Ali, were summoned for questioning by the investigative judge, accused of the same charges. Abeer could not attend the interrogation and Seham, who was reportedly asked about Azza’s activism, was released on bail.
Azza has appealed both the travel ban and the assets freeze decision, finding out that the general prosecutor’s list (the only legal list regarding travel bans) did not include her name and that, in consequence, the travel ban is illegal. After a lengthy judicial procedure, the appeal on the travel ban was rejected. The case she filed against the bank that blocked her account is still ongoing.
Azza Soliman was a witness to a murder of activist Shaimaa ElSabbagh, who was killed while peacefully protesting on 24 January 2015. Two months later, the Qasr El Nile Prosecution Office in Cairo changed Ms Soliman’s status from being a witness to the killing of Shaimaa ElSabbagh to a defendant, accused of protesting illegally. She was acquitted of the charges, which the prosecutor subsequently appealed.
Malek Adly is a prominent human rights lawyer and the director of Lawyers Network at the Egyptian Centre for Economic and Social Rights (ECESR), which seeks to promote and mobilise social movements to spread the culture of human rights.
He is one the founders of the Front for Defending Egypt's Protesters, a group comprising of 34 human rights organisations and several lawyers, which documents illegal practices carried out by state police forces against peaceful protesters.
Upon his arrest in Cairo’s Maadi district on 5 May 2016, Malek Adly was charged with attempting to overthrow the regime, accused of "inciting protests" rejecting the deal between Egypt and Saudi Arabia over two Red Sea islands. He was transferred to Tora prison, where he was reportedly mistreated and beaten in detention, and denied family and lawyer visitation rights.
On 28 August 2016, he was released from prison after having spent nearly 4 months in pre-trial detention in solitary confinement. The charges against him were only dropped in August 2018.
Additionally, in August 2017, Malek Adly was summoned for interrogation by the investigative judge in case 173/2011, known as the Foreign Funding case, accused of conducting activities with the purpose of "harming national security" as an employee at the Hisham Mubarak Law Center in 2010.
He is subject to a travel ban.
Esraa Abdel Fattah
in prison for 41 days
Esraa Abdel Fattah is an Egyptian political activist. She advocates through digital media for human rights and in defence of youth protest movements in Egypt.
On 13 January 2015, Ms Abdel Fattah was prevented from boarding a flight to Germany as police officers at Cairo Airport informed her that a travel ban had been issued against her, without any prior notification.
Ms Abdel Fattah was summoned for interrogation in connection with case no. 173/2011, known as the foreign funding case, on 4 October 2018. She was investigated for participating in the establishment of an entity that received foreign funds and conducted civil society activities without being registered as a civil society organisation. She was released on bail of 10,000 EGP.
On 12 October 2019, Ms Abdel Fattah was arrested from the street and held in an unknown location for 24 hours before appearing in the prosecution, where she was handed a pre-trial detention order in state security case 488/2019 on charges of engaging with a terrorist group to achieve its goals, spreading false news and misusing social media. Her pre-trial detention is now regularly renewed. On the day of her arrest, she was reportedly tortured and subsequently began a hunger strike in protest. The UN Human Rights office has expressed its concerns over her arrest and detention.
In 2008, Ms Abdel Fattah became known for co-founding the April 6 movement during the mass protests against workers’ low wages and increasing food prices. She called for a day of civil disobedience on Facebook that mobilised thousands of young people asking for political change. She was imprisoned for several weeks by the Egyptian security for her role in organising the protest. During the 25th January uprising in 2011, she took a leading role in keeping the media updated about the situation on the ground. She became a symbol of resistance and struggle for women human rights defenders and the youth movement in Egypt, which earned her international attention and recognition. Freedom House awarded her the “New Generation Democratic Activist” prize in 2010; she was nominated “Woman of the Year, 2011” by Glamour magazine and she was among the nominees for the Nobel Peace Prize 2011.
Mozn Hassan is a woman human rights defender and the founder and executive director of Nazra for Feminist Studies (www.nazra.org), a feminist organisation working in Egypt and the MENA region on gender equality and combatting violence against women.
She was summoned to appear before a judge investigating what is known as the “foreign funding case” after her participation at the UN Commission on the Status of Women (CSW) in March 2016.
In June 2016, airport authorities in Cairo prevented her from travelling to Beirut, where she was supposed to participate in the executive committee meeting of the Women Human Rights Defenders Regional Coalition for the Middle East and North Africa, as a regional expert. This travel ban is a clear reprisal measure designed to silence her voice and to stop her from participating in international advocacy.
Ms Hassan also published several articles on the issue of sexual violence against women in the public space and women's political participation.
She is among the 2016 laureates for the Right Livelihood Award, but due to the ban, she has not been able to travel to receive the prize. In 2013, Ms Hassan was awarded the inaugural Charlotte Bunch Human Rights Defender prize at the Global Fund for Women’s 25th Anniversary. Ms Hassan is also a Board Member with the Global Fund for Women and the Association for Women's Rights in Development (AWID), as well as a member of the Regional Experts' Committee of the Regional Coalition for Women Human Rights Defenders in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA).
In January 2017, Ms Hassan's assets were frozen as part of criminal case No. 173/2011, known as the “foreign funding” case.
On 16 March 2018, Nazra for Feminist Studies announced the closing of its headquarters. The decision came 14 months after Ms Hassan's personal assets were frozen as well as the assets of the Nazra company and association. Although the headquarters will be closed, Nazra announced that it will continue to carry out its activities in support of women’s rights.
Gamal Eid is a prominent human rights defender and executive director of the Arabic Network for Human Rights Information (ANHRI). Mr Eid founded ANHRI in 2004 with the aim of establishing an organisation to defend human rights, and freedom of expression in particular, in Egypt and the Arab world through research and legal support to victims. He graduated from Ain Shams University College of Law and served as a defence attorney in several human rights cases during the Mubarak era.
On 4 February 2016, Mr Eid was prevented from boarding a flight to Athens by Cairo Airport officials. He had no prior knowledge, no notification or summons for investigation regarding the travel ban and did not receive any information about the judicial body responsible for it.
On 10 October 2019, Gamal Eid was physically assaulted in the street. The attacker tried to steal his bag and repeatedly beat him with the butt of his gun. The attack was reportedly committed by security personnel. Approximately two weeks later, on 31 October, Mr Eid was borrowing the car of one of his colleagues and he found that it had been smashed. Mr Eid's own car had been stolen on 30 September. He reported these incidents to the police, however the prosecution concluded the investigation abruptly, without hearing his testimony or those of witnesses.
Mohamed Zaree has been the Egypt Office Director of the Cairo Institute for Human Rights Studies (CIHRS) since 2014. He leads CIHRS’ research, human rights education, media outreach and national advocacy activities in Egypt. He also coordinates the Forum of Independent Egyptian Human Rights NGOs, created in 2007.
Since 2012, Mohammed Zaree has represented CIHRS in several official committees charged with drafting a new NGO law for Egypt. He has advocated for freedom of association with different Egyptian ministries under the presidencies of the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces, Mohammad Morsi and Adly Mansour.
On 26 May 2016, Mohamed Zaree was stopped at Cairo International Airport before boarding a flight for a business trip. The officers informed him that a travel ban had been imposed on him, based on an order by the investigative judge of the case no 173/2011, known as the “foreign funding case.”
Mohamed Zaree is a leading protagonist of Egypt’s human rights movement and remains the representative of CIHRS in Egypt. However, his personal safety and freedom are at risk due to the prosecution of the foreign funding case, which targets many human rights defenders in Egypt. As part of the repressive pre-trial measures, CIHRS’ assets were frozen on 17 September 2016.
In October 2017, Mohammed Zaree received the Martin Ennals Award for Human Rights Defenders. Zaree could not attend the ceremony as he remains banned from travelling. His wife and two daughters travelled to Geneva to receive the award on his behalf.
Negad El Borai
Negad El Borai is a prominent human rights lawyer and a well-known figure in Egypt’s civil society. He chairs the law firm United Group for Law, which provides legal support to civil society organisations and victims of human rights violations. The firm also engages in monitoring and documentation of human rights violations pertaining to freedom of expression and opinion, and conducts workshops to raise awareness on these issues.
In March 2015, the High Judicial Council filed a complaint against him for drafting a law for the prevention of torture in line with Egypt’s international commitments, organising a workshop for open discussion with other experts and advocating for its promulgation before the Egyptian authorities. Since then, he has been summoned on five occasions and arrested for “implementing human rights activities without a license”, “deliberately spreading false information with the purpose of harming public order or public interest” and “receiving illegal funds”.
In July 2017, an administrative court banned United Group from conducting human rights activities; endorsing the Social Affairs Ministry’s decision to prohibit the law firm’s recognition as a civil society group for purportedly violating the Law on associations and non-governmental organizations (Law 84/2002).
Negad El Borai is currently under a travel ban that hinders his peaceful work. The travel ban, based on the controversial foreign funding case, was notified to him in January 2017 as he attempted to attend a conference in Jordan.
Mr Ahmed Ragheb is a lawyer and founder of the National Community for Human Rights and Law (NCHRL). He is also one of the founders of the Hisham Mubarak Law Center. He works to promote and protect human rights through NCHRL and in his capacity as a lawyer.
On 15 November 2016, Mr Ahmed Ragheb was told by passport control officials at Cairo International Airport that he was banned from travelling based on a judicial order issued against him in May 2016 by an investigative judge. He was travelling to Morocco to participate in the 22nd session of the Conference of the Parties (COP 22) of the United Nations Climate Change Conference. The order was issued without prior notification and without known charges against him.
In July 2017, Mr Ragheb was interrogated and released on bail in relation to case 173/2011, known as the foreign funding case. He has been charged with receiving funds intended to harm national interest and establishing an organisation without registration in relation to his role at the Hisham Mubarak Law Center.
Abdel Hafez Tayel
Abdel Hafez Tayel is the founder of the Egyptian Center for the Right to Education, an organisation promoting human rights education in Egypt.
On 17 September 2016, the Cairo Criminal Court confirmed the order to freeze his personal assets based on an accusation of illegally receiving foreign funding. If found guilty, he can face up to 25 years of imprisonment.
In November 2016, Abdel Hafez Tayel was heading to Kuwait to attend an international conference on education when airport authorities detained him for several hours before ordering him to head home. He was banned from travelling.
In June 2017, Abdel Hafez Tayel was summoned for interrogation, formally charged and interrogated by the investigative judge in the "foreign funding case" against NGOs. Tayel is accussed of receiving foreign funding with the aim of harming national security, establishing the independent Teachers' Union in violation of the law, tax evasion and “moral fraud”.
Tayel has also been questioned about an article he wrote calling ex-President Mubarak a criminal.
Aida Seif Al-Dawla
One of the founders of Al-Nadeem Center for Rehabilitation of Victims of Violence, she was issued a travel ban on 23rd November 2016 on the basis of her involvement in an unspecified court case.
She had not received any prior notice of the ban from the public prosecutor, but an officer at the airport, where she was first stopped, suggested her lawyer gave the wrong address.
The Al-Nadeem Center’s rehabilitation clinic was threatened with closure in February 2016 following a dispute with the Health Ministry over the legality of the team's advocacy work against torture. The closure was executed a year later in 2017 and is currently being contested by the center in court.
Nasser Amin is the director of the Arab Centre for the Independence of the Judiciary and the Legal Profession in Egypt, as well as the Chairman of the Complaints Committee of the quasi-official National Council for Human Rights. He has worked on cases of enforced disappearances and torture, which he has described as a systematic pattern.
On the 14 July 2016, he was prevented from travelling to Beirut for a conference by the security officers at Cairo International airport based on an order of the Public Prosecutor. The reason behind the travel ban was not stated by the authorities.
Hoda Abd El-Wahab
Hoda Abd El-Wahab is a lawyer and Executive Director of the Arab Centre for the Independence of the Judiciary and the Legal Profession, a regional organisation established in Cairo in March 1997
On 20 June 2016, she was travelling to Oslo to participate in an international conference on the death penalty when she was informed by officials at Cairo International Airport that a judicial order imposed a travel ban on her. Hoda Abd El-Wahab believes that this is related to case 173/2011, known as the foreign funding case against NGOs in Egypt, which was reopened in 2016. She was not formally notified of this order and has yet to be informed of any further action to be taken.
Hossam Al-Din Ali
On 27 February 2016, the director of the Egyptian Democratic Academy, Hossam Al-Din Ali, was stopped at Cairo International Airport and barred from travelling to the United States. He was on his way to an international conference on ways to fight corruption. He discovered his travel ban at Cairo international airport, as he had not been notified of it.
Hossam Bahgat is an Egyptian human rights defender and investigative journalist. He is the founder of the Egyptian Initiative for Personal Rights and a journalist for Mada Masr. He was arrested from 8 to 10 November 2015, summoned by military intelligence for ‘publishing false news that harmed national interests and disseminating information that disturbed public peace’. He had written a series of articles concerning the army and military trials.
In January 2016, he was again critical of the Egyptian regime, when he argued that the ‘level of repression now [is] significantly higher than it was under the Mubarak regime’.
In February 2016, he was prevented from traveling to Jordan in order to participate in a United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia conference on justice in the Arab world.
On 17 September 2016, the Cairo Criminal Court confirmed the order to freeze his personal assets.
Omar Hazek is a human rights defender, a renowned poet from Alexandria and an honorary member of the Austrian chapter of PEN International. He has been an outspoken critic of the use of torture by the Egyptian police and of corruption in public institutions.
In 2013 he was sentenced to two years in prison for allegedly protesting without authorisation. He was released in February 2015 following a Presidential pardon
Hazek was on his way to The Hague to accept the 2016 Oxfam Novib/PEN Award for Freedom of Expression, the award is given annually to honour writers who have fought courageously for freedom of expression in the face of great adversity and despite the risk to their own lives. When he arrived at Cairo airport he was detained, questioned and later released after several hours of questioning, along with being given a travel ban.
In February 2017, Egyptian security services detained Hazek for hours in an unknown location.
About the Campaign
This information page is an initiative by EuroMed Rights to gather public support for
- the release of all Egyptian activists currently held in prison
- the end of growing harassment from the Egyptian authorities
Egyptian activists are striving for human rights, democracy and other fundamental freedoms, yet have been targeted since 2011 for their role in defending and promoting civil, political and economic rights. Due to their prominent contribution in initiating change, many Egyptian activists are being targeted, threatened, prosecuted in political trials and sentenced to long prison terms.
In Egyptian President Sisi’s own words, “(…) there are many innocent people inside prisons, soon many of them will be released according to the available permissions” (declared on television on 22 February 2015)
This systematic crackdown on dissent must stop. All detained activists must be freed and this permanent harassment ended!
Take action and show your support and solidarity.
Every voice counts! Help us in getting as many as possible!
"Putting peaceful activists behind bars may give the authorities a feeling of control, but it’s illusory – and it’s certainly not the road to building a democratic political system."